Ghost tweeting? Remember 80/20 Twitter rule

There’s been much debate over whether companies should outsource their Twitter accounts to their advertising and public relations agencies.  Discussions have largely focused on whether an outsider speaking on behalf of the company expresses authenticity and transparency.

That’s a good point, but here’s the real issue for companies to think about.  Approximately 80 percent of Twitter is about retweeting and having “conversations” with others.  Just 20 percent is about posting your own tweets. Your agency can probably do a fine job on that 20 percent. But are they trained and steeped in company issues enough to respond to the 80% of questions, complaints, and off-topic musings?  Probably not.

As Twitter goes mainstream now is the time for companies to create an enterprise strategy for Twitter, addressing such issues as:

  • Own your name: Make sure your company has its Twitter domain, e.g., Twitter.com/yourname.  If you’re too late, you may have to get involved with name squatters. Here’s a helpful Wall St. Journal piece on the topic.
  • What do customers want: Think about what your customers want to be able to do/get from your company on Twitter, and then create Twitter strategies to support those wants. Pay special attention to areas  like customer service, training, product news, areas where people are beginning to expect to be able to get help via Twitter.
  • Managed by business functions vs. social media dept.: Rather than have a separate social media function managing Twitter, I highly recommend incorporating Twitter into  business functions.  Doing so makes sure that the  80 % “conversations” are staffed by he people who can provide the most helpful and valuable information, and that they support business objectives.
  • Put an enterprise listening platform in place, with specialized keywords and accounts for each business area involved in social media.  Make sure the platform helps your people be responsive, e.g, storing answers to commonly asked questions, featuring flagging capabilities so you rate the urgency of the Tweet and know if someone is addressing it.
  • Have escalation guidelines: Develop  guidelines on how emerging trends, positive and negative, will be escalated — what are the criteria, who in the company will be alerted to what within what time frame, and what kind of action should be taken and then noted in the system so others in the company know the issue is being addressed.
  • Find the insights: Lastly, create a strategy for mining social media conversations about your company, industry and competitors to uncover insights that the business can act on. I’ve seen clients find ideas for new products, new customers, and new brand building programs.  This is a rich, rich market research opportunity that few companies are fully taking advantage of.

Remember the 80/20 rule

The  number of Tweets or Twitter followers does not help build a  brand or the business — especially if the Tweets are randomly pushing out information, or the company Twitter is  trying to follow as many people as possible. I know this sounds so obvious. But every day I hear about companies who are being advised by agencies to “hire someone (meaning the agency) and pump up their Twitter volume.”

Pushing out that 20 percent is easy to “pump up the volume.”  The real value of Twitter comes from the other 80 percent, where people are getting useful and responsive information from a company that they can trust.

A CEO's Twitter advice

smiley face JPEGMost companies tell employees what NOT to Tweet about, but Tony Hsieh, CEO of Zappos.com, suggests to employees that they Tweet about these three things:

  1. What will cause my followers to smile
  2. What will enrich people’s perspective
  3. What will inspire

Thanks to Hollie Delaney of Zappos.com, for sharing this yesterday during out social media session at The Conference Board conference on extending your brand to employees. Thanks too to the other super-smart and generous panelists — Marietta Cozzi of Prudential Financial, Kat Drum of Starbucks, and Kelle Thompson of Liberty Mutual.

CEO's Twitter advice to employees

smiley face JPEGMost companies tell employees what NOT to Tweet about, but Tony Hsieh, CEO of Zappos.com, suggests to employees that they Tweet about these three things:

  1. What will cause my followers to smile
  2. What will enrich people’s perspective
  3. What will inspire

Thanks to Hollie Delaney of Zappos.com, for sharing this yesterday during out social media session at The Conference Board conference on extending your brand to employees. Thanks too to the other super-smart and generous panelists — Marietta Cozzi of Prudential Financial, Kat Drum of Starbucks, and Kelle Thompson of Liberty Mutual.

Responses to Marketing News Radio questions

Really enjoyed the great questions from Wednesday’s  AMA Marketing News Radio program, “Beyond Buzz: Succeeding in a Conversational Marketing 2.0 World,” hosted by the gracious and smart David Kinard. Here are responses to questions that we didn’t have time to get to during the show. Thanks for tuning in!

Can social networking marketing strategies work for B2B industries?  If so, how do we find the relevant networks for our industry (in my case, it happens to be architectural and commercial development)?

Absolutely. Set up several Google Alerts with key words about your industry to begin to see places. Think about using key words that will bring up social networks, like “Industrial architect forums” or” industrial architect blogs.” To see how large the community or blog might be go to Compete, plug in the URL and it will tell give you the # of unique site visitors. Another tip: when using Google use search term “top ten architecture blogs.” I find those top-ten lists a good way to find good sites.

Is there somewhere I can go to learn the practical how-to’s for setting up Twitter, Flickr, YouTube and other similar web programs?  Every talk I hear seems to say how important they are, but none take the time to walk through exactly how to set them up or use them.

Here’s a great list of “how to” blog posts on those topics. Very detailed.   Another source can be found here. (Great little instructional videos.)

I work for a contemporary art gallery and our Internet service currently rests on the city’s server. Therefore, we are blocked from such sites as Facebook and MySpace. We’re not even allowed to post pictures on flikr or Kodak gallery, etc. The city sees them as non-work related sites, understandably. Any suggestions on how we should “pitch” to the city how necessary it is for us to have access to these social communication tools?

Here’s a BBC report on why “Bosses should embrace Facebook” based on a new study.  To make your case find additional data and examples to show how governments – city, state and local – are using social media to be more effective, responsive and citizen-friendly. Build they case for the trend; create a Google Alert “Government use of social media.” (Here’s one example)  Gather the best facts and examples and enlist other organizations like yours who feel the same way. Maybe even start a local social movement, using a blog or Facebook, to raise visibility of the issue. Get some ideas on how to force change from this post, Social media lessons from union organizers.

What tools do you use to track conversation re: your product on the web?

There’s a whole host of tools you can use to track conversations, from the free Google Alerts to Radian6 (low-to-mid) to TruCast from Visible Technologies (mid-to-high). The right choice depends on your business needs. If you’re not doing anything yet, at a minimum set up Google Alerts about your company, your category, industry trends in your field.

And to track conversations on Twitter try services such as Twilert, which will email you once a day with mentions of the keywords you care about, or set up a dashboard on Tweetdeck or Tweetgrid which you can configure and bookmark in your browser to track keywords about your company, products and competitors.

Once we’ve established a presence on a social network, and have the current social networkers buzzing, how do we drive potential customers to that network?

Promote the value (and URL) of the social network to your customers in all the ways you communicate with them.  Emails, brochures, sales presentations, “on hold” telephone message, on employees’ email signatures, etc. Also make it easy for people to tell others about the network by including a lot of social sharing tools in the network to- email, delicious tags, Digg, Twitter, Stumpleupon, Facebook.

Also keep an eye out for particularly engaged members who you can enlist and empower to act as ambassadors for the network.

You referred to the Air Force formula to use as a guideline. Where would I locate that?

You can find it here.

What the pitfalls or key things to look our for when using Facebook or LinkedIn for recruiting and positioning/branding?

The pitfall is using it as a one-way message board promoting your company.  The way to get value is to provide value. You have to give to get.

Use these networks to provide information that’s helpful and interesting to your audience. Or use it o ask questions, like “we’re looking for a sales executive with xx years experience in the xyz industry; compensation: $120-150k.  Know anyone?”    Guy Kawasaki offers this good advice, “Ten Ways to Use Linked In for Business.” Note, however, that Facebook and LinkedIn do have their limitations. For many businesses, there’s not a whole lot of value for them with Facebook.

I suspect that there will be discussion about social networking sites and their effectiveness as a relationship building/marketing tool.

Most definitely. You can find much more information about this topic in this free e-book, Marketing in 2009.

Any other questions? If so, please add them here and I’ll get back to you. Again, thanks for listening.

Verizon uses twittering teddy bear spokesperson for "credibility" (hee hee)

In an age where people are tired of marketing hype and gimmicks, it seems odd that Verizon would decide to use a teddy bear as the spokesperson for its FiOs marketing campaign. What’s even odder is that the teddy Twitters, reaching an audience that is even more suspect of inauthentic marketing.

Jason Chupick of Campfire, the agency designing the campaign, explains in today’s PR Week:

“[We] needed a spokesperson, an ongoing voice that people will listen to because everyone is trying to come up with a novel Twitter campaign.”

If the teddy is really bizarre it just might become a viral hit. But sorry Verizon and Campfire, a teddy bear isn’t an a”voice” that this consumer is going to listen to, never mind take seriously.